It was as good as they could make it while making it still accessible to the general public. Rumor has it the original was 5-6 hours long but was cut for obvious reasons. Book is always bettter but I think they did a good job for what they were limited to. Into comics or not, read the damn thing and you'll like the movie loads better

It was pretty good in my opinion, but definitely has very mixed reactions. Two of the actors are fantastic (Jackie Earle Haley and Jeffery Dean Morgan) but most of the others fall a little flat. It's worth a watch for sure, but the comic is better.

i was hoping better.... to be honest- it sucked !!

Definately watch it. I liked it it wasn't the best film but it was good. I know some people who don't like it that much but if u wanna watch something that's different watch it.

I'm also a girl who was never into superhero comics, and it was a really good movie. I would honestly have to tell you to read the book after or before the movie, because some people who watched it without reading it didn't get the gist of it at all. It is kind of confusing at times.

It's kind of like Fight Club, if you've ever seen it. If you don't pay attention to the whole movie, you'll most likely be lost.

well i never actually read the comics, so going into it i didnt know much about it, to be honest i was a bit let down by it, i found i was always waiting for it to begin, it was a pretty good movie, and as scott said they made it as good as they could have made it.